The review of this book that I read was by a native Ohioan, enthusiastic about the attention to his state in this slow-moving novel about four people over the course of most of the 20th century. It was set in a fictional small town, with references to actual nearby towns in Ohio and a midwest sensibility. I’ve seen it described as an old-fashioned novel, telling the story of peoples’ lives from beginning to end and while that is accurate, the telling is not always linear, but is recounted in pleasingly unconventional ways.
Among the four, there’s an orphan, a gay person, one with a disability, and one able to make connections with people who have died. It is the story of how the four came together as couples, how those couples became intertwined, and how each dealt with their unusual qualities in a time that was less tolerant of difference than our own time. Each of them became far more than the one quality mentioned above, but that quality is key. Margaret had a child, but was unable to be a mother, and like her own mother did, she abandoned him. (Is that a little too on-the-nose?) The smart and talented Felix must marry, which didn’t work for him or the woman he married. The most centered and sure of herself is Becky, who was able to reach the spirits of those who had died and for many years brought relief to many people while not taking any money and not being duped by those who would exploit her. Cal has one leg shorter than the other and his limp set him apart from others as a kid and kept him from the war. The Second World War has an outsized impact on the characters and the effects reverberate over the years after the war.
Two boys, one from each of the couples, became friends despite a two-year age difference, after Skip, the older one, protected Tom from bullies. One day when they got together, it was to bicycle to Skip’s house where they collected buckeyes from the tree in the yard. They rode to an abandoned mill, climbed to a platform where they could use Skip’s slingshot to shoot buckeyes aiming at birds they couldn’t possibly hit, along with crop dusters, cars, or just straight overhead. Skip thought they were out of buckeyes, but Tom had stuffed more in his socks. Skip found this hilarious and from that day, called him Buckeye. I found that an endearing passage and of course, a nice reference to Ohio’s official tree.
We marched on through much of the century and there were references to the upheavals of the times after the 1950s as well as upheavals within those family dynamics.
Patrick Ryan, Buckeye, Random House, 2025, 452 pages (I listened to the audiobook). Available in the public library.